Topic | Study | Year of publication | Study design | Evidence level | Cleft | Aim of the study |
Sample size |
Control group |
Method assessment |
Effect of nasal molding | Effect of alveolar molding | Other Outcomes | Follow-up | Study limit |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Three-dimensional analysis (CAD) |
Singh et al. [61] | 2007 | Prospective study | II | UCLP | Evaluate with three-dimensional stereophotogrammetry the facial morphology after NAM |
25 (NAM + surgery: 15) |
No cleft: 10 |
Digital stereophotogrammetry used to capture three-dimensional facial image | Three-dimensional facial morphology virtually indistinguishable from the non-cleft | - | - | 37 weeks + 4 weeks after surgery | - |
Baek and Son [62] | 2006 | Prospective study | II | UCLP | Assess alveolar molding effect and growth with CAD | 16 | NA | CAD | - | Reduction cleft gap | - | 2 months after cheilioplasty | No control group | |
Singh et al. [63] | 2005 | Prospective study | III | UCLP | Evaluate three-dimensional change nasal morphology with NAM | 10 | NA | Three-dimensional facial image captured with digital stereophotogrammetry | Size increase on the cleft and non-cleft side. Symmetry improved | - | - | Before surgical repair | No control group | |
Three-dimensional analysis (CAD) and printing (CAM) | Shen et al. [53] | 2015 | Prospective study | II | UCLP | Evaluate effect three-dimensional printing NAM | 17 | None | Measured on three-dimensional computed tomography scans before and after NAM treatment | - | Alveolus became more contiguous and cleft gap was reduced | 11 patients had mucosal irritation, minor mucosal ulceration, decrease cost of treatment | Post treatment (before cheiloplasty) | - |
Yu et al. [64] | 2013 | Randomized control study | II | UCLP | Evaluate efficiency of CAD-NAM therapy (7 - 10 pairs of appliances) |
30 (CAD-NAM treated: 15) |
Non-presurgical therapy: 15 | Measurement on scanned cast | - | Reduce cleft gap and arch length. Decrease alveolar high | - | Average 123 days | - |
UCLP = unilateral cleft lip and/or palate; BCLP = bilateral cleft lip and/or palate; CAD/CAM = computer-aided design/computer-assisted manufacture. |