Study | Population | Gender | Age | Study group | Observation period | Treatment outcome | Results | Conclusion |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Male/female | Years | |||||||
Yüce et al. [15] | Female osteoporotic patients with stage 2 or 3 MRONJ underwent surgical treatment of MRONJ | Control: 0/14 |
Control: 73.64 (SD 5.49) |
Control (n = 14): treated with sequestrectomy and bone curettage without application of CGF | 6 months | Treatment was considered successful if had soft tissue coverage in the surgical site without signs of infection and/or necrotic bone. |
Control: 6 healed (42.9%), 8 unhealed (57.1%) |
Local application of CGF appears to be an effective approach to the surgical treatment by improving tissue regeneration (P = 0.232) |
Test: 0/14 |
Test: 73.57 (SD 5.1) |
Test (n =14): treated with a local application of CGF on the surgical site after removing the necrotic bone |
Test: 11 healed (78.6%), 3 unhealed (21.4%) |
|||||
Park et al. [17] | Patients with stage 1 - 3 MRONJ and underwent surgical treatment of MRONJ. | Control: 3/22 | 75.24 | Control (n = 25): surgical debridement of MRONJ lesion followed by application of L-PRF on bony defect | Control: 6 - 26 months | Treatment was considered successful if had mucosal coverage with absence of clinical or radiographical evidence of MRONJ at 4 weeks postoperatively. |
- Complete resolution.
Control: 9 patients (36%); test: 18 patients (60%). - Delayed resolution. Control: 13 patients (52%); test: 11 patients (36.7%). - No resolution. Control: 3 patients (12%); test: 1 patient (3.3%). |
L-PRF with BMP-2 therapy led to beneficial outcomes with complete resolution of the lesions, which were statistically significant when compared to L-PRF therapy alone (P = 0.028) |
Test: 29/1 | 75.2 | Test (n = 30): surgical debridement of MRONJ lesion and application of L-PRF and rhBMP-2 on bony defect | Test: 6 - 31 months | |||||
Guo and Guo [20] | Patients with stage 2 or 3 MRONJ and underwent surgical treatment of MRONJ. | Control: 10/8 | 62.17 (SD 2.8) | Control (n = 18): treated with conventional approach-sequestrectomy and curettage | 30 months | Treatment was considered successful if had complete mucosal coverage without bone exposure, fistula and relapse |
Control: 4 healed (22.22%), 14 relapse (77.78%) |
The test group's rate of treatment success was significantly greater (P = 0.005) |
Test: 6/4 | 63.5 (SD 3.38) | Test (n = 10): treated with sequestrectomy and curettage with cortical perforations of the residual healthy bone. |
Test: 8 healed (80%), 2 relapse (20%) |
|||||
Szentpeteri et al. [21] | Patients with stage 2 or 3 MRONJ and underwent surgical treatment of MRONJ. | 74/27 | Control: 63.97 | Control (n = 73): surgical open flap debridement of MRONJ lesion |
T1 = 1 week; T2 = 2 weeks; T3 = 1 month; T4 = 3 months; T5 = 6 months; T6 = 1 year |
Treatment was considered successful if had staging improvement according to the AAOMS, no relapse.
Osteonecrosis assessed by X-ray |
- Wound healing.
Control: 38 cases (58.46%); test: 23 cases (82.14%). - Down-staging. Control: l54 cases (77.14%); test: 100% of cases. - Relapse. Control: 25 cases (65.78%); test: 5 cases (21.73%) |
PRF membrane-assisted surgical therapy greatly increased stage improvement and healing rates (P = 0.022) and down staging (P = 0.005) as well as significantly decreased relapse rates (P < 0.001) |
Test: 68.42 | Test (n = 28): surgical open flap debridement of MRONJ lesion and defect coverage with 2 PRF membranes. | |||||||
Şahin et al. [22] | Patients with stage 2 or 3 MRONJ and underwent surgical treatment of MRONJ | 7/14 | 68.04 (SD 9.82) | Ultrasonic piezoelectric bone surgery was used to remove the necrotic bone. Following debridement, the patient's peripheral blood was centrifuged to obtain L-PRF, which was then administered to the necrotic site |
T1 = 1 month; T2 = 3 months; T3 = 6 months; T4 = 12 months |
Treatment was considered successful if had complete mucosal, bone covering and the absence of the symptom | T1 = 2 stage III patients had delayed healing. T2, T3, T4 = all patients had complete mucosal healing | The surgical procedure shown yields encouraging results. |
MRONJ = medication-related osteonecrosis of the jaw; T = follow-up time; CGF = concentrated growth factor; PRF = platelet-rich fibrin; L-PRF = leukocyte rich and platelet-rich fibrin; BMP-2 = bone morphogenetic protein-2; AAOMS = The American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons; SD = standard deviation. |