Study | Materials used | Type of sinus lift | Residual alveolar height (mm) | Statistical difference | Average augmented graft height (mm) | Statistical difference | Average resorption height (mm) |
Follow-up (months) |
Statistical difference | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Study group | Comparison group | Study group | Comparison group | Study group | Comparison group | |||||||
Jun et al. [15] |
Study group: autoBT; Comparison group: Bio-Oss® |
Lateral window approach | 3.12 (SD 1.17) | 3.17 (SD 1.26) |
Not significant (P = 0.889) |
10.73 (SD 2.08) | 10.45 (SD 2.56) |
Not significant (P = 0.709) |
Not evaluated | Not evaluated | 4 | Not evaluated |
Jeong et al. [16] |
Study group: autoBT; Comparison group: DFDBA, DBBM |
Lateral window approach | 3.3 - 10 |
DFDBA: 1.7 - 10.6; DBBM: 4.9 - 10.3 |
Not evaluated | 9.07 (SD 2.92) |
DFDBA: 10.95 (SD 2.75); DBBM: 11.83 (SD 2.81) |
Not significant (P = 0.182) |
1.27 (SD 1.06) |
DFDBA: 1.53 (SD 0.71); DBBM: 1.37 (SD 1.09) |
6 |
Not significant (P = 0.576) |
Kim et al. [17] |
Study group: autoBT; Comparison group: Osteon™ |
Crestal approach | 9.64 | 9.22 |
Not significant (P = 0.973) |
4.89 | 6.22 |
Not significant (P = 0.46) |
0.76 | 0.53 | 12 |
Not significant (P = 0.57) |
Kim et al. [18] |
Study group: autoFDT + PRP; Comparison group: allograft + xenograft + PRP |
Lateral window approach | 1.2 - 4.2 | 1.55 - 3.85 |
Not significant (P = 0.233) |
11.62 (SD 2.22) | 13.65 (SD 1.35) |
Significant (P = 0.007) |
1.23 (SD 0.73) | 1.77 (SD 0.54) | 24 |
Not significant (P = 0.021) |
DFDBA = demineralized freeze-dried bone allograft; DBBM = deproteinized bovine bone mineral; autoFDT = autogenous fresh demineralized tooth; autoBT = autogenous tooth bone graft; PRP = platelet-rich plasma. |